Six months after the events of "The Revelations of Gavin Grey", Ricky finds himself dealing with the consequences of his brother's actions in ways he never imagined while his mothers have to make an unbearable decision.
The death of their son, Gavin, has caused turmoil for Alice and Olivia as one confronts her past and the other has a hard time letting go.
Jordan Bohn returns to her hometown after years away because being there reminds her of her abusive father. She runs into her ex-boyfriend, Ryan Smith, at the train station and they go to their old haunt, the diner. During lunch, Jordan realizes the past isn't really past.
